Papa's Pizza

This place has the most freaking amazing deep dish pizza I've ever eaten in my life. It has the perfect meld of flavors. I think we had one piece left and we bought two pizzas that evening... Papa's mostly advertises their thin crust and that's amazing but the deep dish is where it's at. I honestly cannot recommend it enough

In my unrelenting quest to find the most exquisite pizza ever created, I discovered Papa’s Pizza in Montague, MI. Arriving at this pizzeria felt like coming home with timeless décor, family games, and an ever-present charm. We ordered a smorgasbord of delectable treats. Starting with the Papa Whoppa, a sub with all the meats, it was especially wonderful thanks to their unique sauce, and the sandwich was perfectly toasted. The Super Pizza arrived next thanks to Papa Pizza’s unparalleled service. This pizza was beyond fantastic. The soft, thinner crust was wonderful, but the sauce with all toppings was the icing on this extra tasty pie. Waiting only a short time later, the Deluxe Cheese Deep Dish was delivered to our table. This pie was simply incredible. The star of the show was the molt

We just left and i ran to give a review! The people running it amazing, the food amazing! Id advise ordering ahead if you get deep dish pizza (do it!) and definitely eat in! Oh and try the lettuce sauce.

On 01/23/2026, I ordered 4 orders of bone-in wings take-out. I requested all four orders with sauce. After pick-up I looked at all 4 orders at my residence. Three orders had sauce, one order was without sauce. Do better Papas.

Very friendly staff. Awesome customer service! The pizza is absolutely fabulous. Tried the chicken, bacon ranch Sicilian style. Also tried the wet burrito. The food was top notch!