Pauls Live From New York Pizza Arcata

I had been craving a slice of pizza for a few weeks and I made the drive to arcata for their lunch special! 10.99 plus tax for a great salad delicious pizza and fountain drink! I got the farmers market pizza absolutely delicious! Thank you!

Best pizza in Humboldt! Classic, NY style - delicious! Lots of choices and gluten free options. The Olive Special is excellent.

If you haven’t tried the meatballs in marinara- you are depriving yourself of the best meatballs some girl on google reviews ever boasted about. They are so good! The marinara is amazing and the fresh basil really sets it off. The service is also just as amazing- the employee who consistently wears jordans and basketball shorts always goes above and beyond. You wont regret stopping by!

I have to recant my rating. I wanted to order a reg.Veggie pizza but they don't have that.So I went back and forth with the girl taking my order. I asked for bell peppers, olives, mushrooms, basil and garlic. after 20 minutes of her not knowing the difference between vegan and gluten free. I ended up with a gluten free Pizza with NO bell peppers. I used to love this place but, come on! don't most pizza places have a veggie pizza. I think the place has gone down hill. the front is dirty

Loved the atmosphere, beer selection with happy hour specials, and amazing service. The staff here is great and accommodating. The salads and cannolis are great, but my gripe is the cheese on the $30 pizza had zero stretch and flavor. The crust was dry and lacked flavor as well.