Pennie's Bake Shop & Espresso Bar

I called on Monday to have a custom cake made to surprise my husband and in laws with a gender reveal. The cake was ready on Wednesday and the cake was even better than I imagined. The details were correct. The cake was not dry at all and delicious. They have a lot of great flavors to offer. Staff were very friendly and called to confirm details the day before. A very cute atmosphere inside too. I’d definitely come back for coffee and a treat.

Cute bakery in Butler. So glad I found it. Great cold brew, I had the peppermint bark one! Yummy wedding cake and peanut butter cookie. I'll be back! The young ladies were friendly and helpful.

Wow, Wowzers, Amazing, Delicious, Undeniably best bakery ever experienced! Amazing treats and hot drinks! Highly recommend and will stop anytime we are in the area! Pricey but worth every “penny”!

I will scream to the heavens that Pennie’s is an amazing bakery! The staff was so kind, Hannah was a pleasure. They were able to make this beautiful cake for me sorta last minute. Not only did it look fantastic, but it tasted great too. Everyone was asking where we got it and said it was great. I could not be more pleased (and the birthday girl was ECSTATIC). Thank you to everyone at Pennies! I will be a returning customer!

Pennie's serves some of the best coffee I’ve had anywhere hands down! They use Onyx Coffee Lab beans, which puts them in the top tier globally and shows how seriously they take their craft. I’ve traveled extensively and seek out top-tier coffee shops everywhere, and Pennie’s consistently holds its own against the best. The staff is genuinely friendly, and their cookies, pastries, and cakes are excellent, but the coffee alone is reason enough to come back again and again. If you care about TRULY GREAT COFFEE, this place is a must!