PEPPERONI'S PIZZERIA

My first time ordering here. Ordered by phone and picked up. Food was still hot after getting it home. Pizza wasn't bad, I liked it. Corn nuggets were good. Ordered garlic knots and got 4 bread sticks, and no one said anything about auto substituting or being out of garlic knots on pick up, so I just assume I was just given the wrong item. The bread sticks were all right, nothing impressive. Ordered a greek veggie calzone, and I just couldn't tolerate it and started feeling sick to my stomach after trying to. I know it says it's made with fresh garlic (which, to me, means not garlic powder etc, but at least cooked), instead the calzone had a whole lot of huge chunks of raw garlic (which, to me, is completely unappetizing, not palatable, and was very hard on my stomach). Marinara was alrig

Wanting pizza, so I got the lunch special. Staff was pleasant and knowledgeable. Price and quantity is great! Flavor was average, but you get a good amount of toppings, even on the slices. It tasted as if the cheese pizza was already made, and they added the toppings on it and put it back in the oven. Anyway, nice local place to get some pizza 🍕 😋

⭐5 stars – Pepperoni's is the best pizza in High Springs! We've been coming here regularly and they've never gotten an order wrong. The staff is genuinely friendly and always makes my family feel welcome the moment we walk in. Plenty of parking, super easy to get to, and the place is perfect for a date night or a casual meal with the kids (up to 4 of us no problem). Bonus: the bathrooms are always spotless. Highly recommend—our go-to pizza spot hands down! 🍕

When you pay extra for toppings on a pizza and 5 mushrooms on a half a pizza. The mushrooms were only on 3 small slices. I love your pizzas, but toppings when you pay extra should reflect the 3 extra dollars you spend to have them added

I was a little worried about trying a new pizza place. I'd never heard of it before, but I received one of their menus in the mail. I ordered the Old World Specialty pizza and a Calbrese Calzone. They were both delicious! The pizza was hot, super cheesy (always a great thing), and had little bits of garlic on it that tasted amazing. The Calzone was my favorite though. It is massive and stuffed to the brim with cheese and toppings. It was hands down the best calzone I've ever had. Even though this pizza place is a little expensive, I'll definitely be ordering from there again.