Pier 76

I visited on a weekend for dinner. The atmosphere was quiet, clean and the bartender was polite. I ordered a chicken Alfredo pasta, the flavor was okay, the Parmesan cheese elevated the taste from a 5/10 to a 7/10. I also ordered a calzone with added meat, the calzone was hard, burnt and the meat was tasteless. I swapped it for a salad, the salad was much better than the calzone. Once my order was finalized, I was still charged for the calzone I returned. I chose not to make a big deal about but I will not be back as a customer.

One of my favorite places in Staten Island, and it happens to have some of the top 10, top 25 pizza ratings in nyc. They're part of Joe & Pat's (SI & Manhattan), Rubirosa (Manhattan), Ciro's fame. And it's one of very few restaurants off the ferry, 2 blocks from the Outlets and St. George Theater. It's an old-school Tiffany lamp, awesome Marshall speaker red-checkered table cloth place. The prices are incredible, esp when there are so few restaurants in the area, and the to-go lunch specials are the best. I'll put a pic of that menu since they're not on the website. :)

Wow what a disappointment. Expected a true baked ziti. Instead, I get sauce mixed with a bunch of ricotta - when I specifically asked for light - and absolutely no cheese except a measly slice on top. For $20 this is flavorless and terrible.

Absolutely fabulous!! We are tourists from the UK and WOW!!! These guys have certainly set the tone for the expectations for food/service. Staten island has been super welcoming and the food and service in this place has the best Italian food we've ever eaten(from a European, this is incredibly rare). The authenticity, mannerisms, attitude and welcoming manner screams Italy. Absolutely blown away. They have exceeded every expectation and more! Couldn't recommend this place enough, id even suggest leaving NYC to visit Staten Island just for the pizza. Perfection

The pizza was really excellent. I loved every minute of it. Must recommend!!