Pisillo Italian Panini TIMES SQUARE

Hands down THE best Italian sandwich in NYC. Emmanuel and Pietro are super kind, and experts preparing traditional Sicilian sandwiches with the best ingredients and the freshest bread in New York. They don’t play around with the prosciutto, they stack it on! Number 2, the Napoli, is our favorite. And when I say the sandwiches are amazing, I mean it. They also have tasty beverages imported from Italy to complement your order. Support this local biz and it may be your favorite new spot.

This is absolutely a must stop if you visit New York. Robert De Niro has pics signed on the wall and claims its his favorite deli in NY. He wasn't lying one bit. Freshest and best tasting meats and cheeses ever in my life, 💯. Enjoy whatever but I had roasted chicken with provolone and tomatoes with lettuce. Wonderbarrrr! Plz dont sleep on this oasis for the taste buds! Thank you all. 👍

In all honesty, it did not strike me as the best sandwich spot, but I do not want to give three stars considering that lots of people highly rated this place. A few things to mention: 1) sandwiches are quite big. I think one sandwich is good enough for two. 2) the do not have hot subs. Everything is cold. 3) there is no restroom. I ordered the New York sub and it was no different than the sandwiches that I prepare myself at home. 💁🏻‍♂️

This was potentially the best sandwich I've had in my life, the flavours and textures combined so well. The New York was just the right level of spice. I recommend giving this a try if you're in the neighbour

This is a small sandwich shop primarily geared for pick up. They may look pricy but their portions are enormous; easily enough for 2 meals! The staff are prompt and friendly, and they explain any options you have questions about. Speaking of options, their selection of breads as the base of your sandwich is nothing to scoff at. The fillings themselves have quality that you can taste, and you can watch them assemble it as well. The store interior is filled with photos and eye-catching bits from pictures of Italy to celebrities. They even have some sandwiches named after said celebrities that came to order. Very fun shop