Pizza Mia

I don't usually leave any reviews under 4 stars, and I'm not going to be unfair to the establishment and leave a 1 star, but I was really disappointed with what I got. I ordered a few slices of buffalo pizza and a Caesar salad. The pizza was fine enough. The salad that I was charged $8 (for a small) was extremely lazy and disappointing. It was quite literally lettuce with Caesar dressing. No croutons, no black olives, no fresh Parmesan cheese. Lettuce and Caesar dressing for $8. There's no excuse for that.

Just received my order from you guys and we ordered baked ziti and it tastes absolutely horrible. The sauce is seriously orange and it doesn’t even taste like baked ziti at all. Taste more like mac & cheese with Parmesan mixed in. Not tasteful at all. So upset I had to waste this, because it’s surely not edible. Never ordering this again smh

Very nice place with a friendly atmosphere. For two we ordered 1 slice of pizza with vegetables(you can add all veggies or the ones you like), 1 slice of pizza with chicken with mushroom and onion, and the spinach roll. For drink a glass bottle of Coca-Cola and the glass bottle of their "Classic Pizza" seltzer. All the food was very tasty and deserved each penny from $25. Since we were here 1st time, we shared all the dishes and enjoyed each piece we bit. The dough for the pizza and the roll was thin and crispy (but not overcooked), along with the juicy toppings, making each dish taste unforgettable. I'm living in Brooklyn, but next time I come, I'm going to order the whole large pie with 2 topics, 😋 yummy...

When my family moved into this area 25 years ago the family the runs Classic Pizza were our first friends. Welcoming us with friendship and warm. The pizza and other dishes that they offer provide the same feeling and you can taste it with every bite. There is love and fresh ingredients in everything they make. I don’t know what took me so long to write this review.

Planned a day of hiking the white trail in Staten island. It starts at Willowbrook park off victory Blvd and goes all the way through the green belt to Gateway park on Hylan Blvd. Pretty much exactly at the half way mark on this hike is Classic Pizza. Whenever hiking the white trail I stop in here for a slice or 2 and some ice cold drinks. It's a nice slice! Highly recommend. Went back again and had the meatball pizza. It was delicious. TBH, I think they are the best Meatballs I've ever had!!