Pizza Plus

We're locals in the area but live around 30 minutes away don't go their a lot but definitely frequently. Pizza Plus has always had good pizza never once had a bad slice I have eaten. Over all definitely order ahead of time but don't have much to say except always receive very delicious pizza, staff are very friendly and accommodating.

Decided to stop by this place, being in the area for another event, to give it a try. Unfortunately service and food were disappointing. When picking up we were first almost given someone else’s order and when realizing this, staff made it seem more like our fault than theirs. Customer service skills could use a big bump up here. Regarding the food, average quality for the price. Ordered two pizzas, the larger of which was the better, as the smaller one was burnt all around. Appetizers also did not have much appeal. Overall, seemed like a busy place, but improvements on service and quality would go a long way to making the atmosphere much better.

This is a great pizzeria in the middle of nowhere. The thin crispy crust, real mozzarella cheese and great toppings came together perfectly. It's 2 hours from home, but I will definitely be eating here again.

7/10/24 Back in the area.. you are now closed on Wednesdays. Please update your site. 8/3/23 always stop in when visiting the area and always great food! Old review: Great pizza, fries and soft serve. Only wish we had time to try more items. Friendly staff and great service. I have family in area and having a restaurant of this quality is a very nice plus! We be going here every future visit to the area.

Pretty fantastic pizza for the middle of the Catskills! Perfectly crunchy crust, nothing chewy about it. The crazy statue in the front is also amazing. It's definitely what brought us inside. Pro tip: They sell pizza by the slice so this is a great place to hit if you're on a tight schedule. I have a family of five and we were in and out in 17 minutes!