Pizza Star (Middletown)

I had the best slice of my life! And the best shrimp bisque as well! I tried them for the first time last week and I've already made my third trip. I don't know what the slice was called but it was over over the top! It was Marsala sauce, cheese, chicken, mushrooms, and spinach. I've never had anything like it in my life so so so so good

We've been here several times and not once have we been disappointed. The staff is so friendly and attentive. Wifey loves their mushroom slice. I've tried a bunch of different specialty slices, we've both had their sliders, and their plain slices. This place continues to warm it's place in our top places to eat.

Yes they're special and when they're ordering the big bread from Definitely Middletown, NY is no words how tasty exciting and everything gets. Wait when they will start the regular bread with DeFilippis Bakery in Middletown NY oh mine it will rock.

I ordered the gnocchi which came with salad and bread and it was amazing. The salad was really good with the peppers and olives onions and tomatoes and the pasta had asparagus mushrooms and peppers which I never had before. The service is outstanding everyone is very very polite and kind. They have beautiful Italian instrumental music playing while you eat and tv. I highly recommend this place to eat.

It was a great discovery! We moved to Middletown less than a month ago, and we’ve already ordered the same dish twice — it tastes just as good every time. 10/10.