Plaza Diner

We arrived around 2:30 on a weekday, so it was not very busy. The server was personable and attentive. Prices were surprisingly high, but my partner and I we're not looking for anything heavy. We both got the soup and half sandwich option for $13- a very fair deal. Based on today's experience, I would have expected the diner to have a 4.6-7 rating. My gf said maybe 4.3 for her. I was pleasantly surprised with our experience. That said, I can see how other reviewers' concerns may well be valid. I think we just picked a good day/time to show up.

We wanted to have a quick bite before the movies, and very happy we came here. Our waitress was super nice and helpful. The kids coloring activity was really entertaining. My philly cheesesteak wrap was delicious. If you haven't been here in a while, give it another try.

Food was great! Still typical diner food, and a bit overpriced. However, the food tasted good and the service was wonderful. Recommend if you’re looking for a diner spot while driving through New Paltz.

Been coming for few years now and usually the food and the service is great. But recently me and my boyfriend have been getting served by this Hispanic lady and she makes us feel bit uncomfortable cause she rush us to take our order and she doesn’t even come check on us once after the food is delivered. And we have to go up front to pay. I just found out today that she’s been adding 20% tip without even telling us the tip is added so we’ve been giving additional tip on top of that. I work in service industry and adding tip is fine but u always let the customer know that the tip is being added. We usually always got some other Lady as our server who never added tip so I don’t know if this is a new policy.

$20 for a basic grilled cheese with fries is criminal. They didn't even give me the coleslaw it was supposed to come with. Whole menu was way overpriced, even for todays standards. Go elsewhere