Plymouth Cafe

I popped in to grab a quick lunch sandwich here. It’s very unassuming on the inside, but the really nice man behind the counter made me a DELICIOUS vegetarian cheese sandwich that is exactly how my mom used to make for me. The ingredients and bread were super fresh. I was expecting bodega quality and my expectations were blown away by this little sandwich. This is a cute local gem for sure!

I would give it one star, but giving it two stars because the price was on the cheaper end for this neighborhood. However I ordered a bacon, egg, and cheddar cheese on a roll toasted with butter after he tried to mansplain how to order a breakfast sandwich to me. Then when I got my sandwich there was no butter and American cheese. I tried to ask him if he could fix it. He refused and told me there is butter, but it’s just melted. It was just bacon grease. Mind you, I was the only person in the store, so the fact that he got my entire order wrong is ridiculous.

This is the second time when the man behind the counter has charged me extra 1-2$ And when I am asking for what was 11,35 (I ordered a burger, which is 8.95$) he told me onion and lettuce. Seriously?? I used to come here to get something for lunch, but I won't come back.

Pretty good food, idk why it says there’s Wi-Fi here on Gmap, this is definitely not a Wi-Fi cafe. Owner is really kind and the food came out very quickly.

Freshly baked bagel with cream cheese for only 3.50! Simple local cafe with American specialties, unpretentious atmosphere and friendly service. If you are visiting Brooklyn Heights Promenade and fancy a snack this must be your spot.