Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery

Our book club opted for late brunch for our monthly meet-up. Not a usual spot to host a book club meeting, but we couldn’t turn down pie. Being a Sunday afternoon, the parking lot had ample space, with plenty of seating available. I came in last, but our party of six got a table quite easily with no wait. Their menu is large, classic diner style options with a separate menu just for their desserts. I opted for one of their specials- Brat and Eggs ($13.99) - Menu stated we could choose any bakery item with this choice, but our server said the only thing I could have was their blueberry muffin. I even said I’d pay the difference for a slice of pie. This was probably when I realized service was not going to be great. I had also asked for a Vanilla Cold Brew ($5.29) - specifically asked for it

We have been coming to Polly’s Pies for years! You really can’t go wrong with anything on their menu but really the pancakes and their coffee to me is the best. They even sell the beans and they will grind them for you. I have gone their breakfast just because I wanted to rotate my coffee and theirs into the rotation. My kids LOVE their cinnamon rolls. They are giant so beware. We always get them ahead of time almost like a breakfast appetizer for the table to share. Soooo good. Definitely, a must try. We love Polly’s!

Update- We got a craving some sweets and found this banberry pie while scrolling for a dessert. It arrived in this bright fun color box and on time. The pie traveled well and looked beautiful once we opened the box. It was delicious but the cream was a bit gummy for my taste but others really enjoyed it. The food overall was good. The wedge salad and coconut shrimp hit the spot and tasted good, especially the tangy spicy sauce that had a kick. The sourdough cheeseburger was okay but wasn’t hot which made the bread a bit chewy. The fries weren’t hot either.

Great place for a Sunday dinner. Prime rib was seasoned perfectly, with a nice salty crust and true medium rare. Not bad for $21.99. Coffee was great and so was the chilli. Would highly recommend

My first visit at this location. Ordered french toast combo with sausage and scrambled eggs. My mom ordered the eggs benedict. We also ordered two cappuccinos. We had an amazing time!