Pomodoro Ristorante Italiano

Had a great first time at Pomodoro‘s, where Nocchi jumped up from the plate and gave me a hug! The pink sauce was so delicious. I wanted to take a quart of it home with me to drink. The rustic with wine bottles on display and handmade tiles nestled in a Reno house with a Tuscan/beachy vibe made for a lovely atmosphere. EnJOY! Buona!

After reviewing many reviews by others that were so positive, I am left wondering why our experience was so bad. Perhaps it was just a bad night for them. We ate here on a Friday night one day before Valentines Day. It was filled and the patrons appeared happy and excited. We had a party of eight (8). Immediately I noticed how loud it was: a bit too loud for my senses. Bread and marinara greeted us at the table: a nice intro I thought - different. But the Italian bread was stale and hard and when I asked for replacements I was told that their bread was provided by an independent vendor and it is what it is. Service was slow and chaotic. You would think that a restaurant looks forward to weekend nights and would be fully prepared to handled the volume of tables and patrons. But, no, it was

I took a getaway from Los Angeles, and headed to paradise. I spent the night on Shelter Island and wanted to get some pasta. I saw a few reviews and thought why not- Jared greeted me at the entrance and ended up being my waiter- He took care of me right away- I tasted the home made bread, but what got me was the sauce- I was going to order garlic and olive oil- game changer- I had the Norma Al Forno I believe, eggplant, mozzarella, potatoes, and of course the sauce. I will be back Jared was awesome and the food was delicious

The service was good, the whole team was on it showing the true definition of teamwork. I’m from New York just moved here so I know real legit Italian food. I had the veal Parmesan and veal is tricky because if you over cook it . You get that chewy flavor this was cooked perfect. I went the chef Benjamin to thank him. This man is a Rock Star . Pomodoro is amazing , respect to the truly incredible staff thank you 🙏🏼

An authentic Italian restaurant with AMAZING food. We were greeted with fresh bread and marinara dipping sauce. One friend had a huge portion of Lasagna (still can't believe he finished in one sitting). Another friend had Spaghetti Carbonara, and I had Capallini Mari E Monte (angel hair pasta with 5 jumbo shrimp and spicy marinara). The flavor of all the dishes were OUTSTANDING. I will definitely visit again.