Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth

I once tried to order a pizza here because I learned about pizza in the Super Mario Bros Super Show and the time I watched it and mario mentioned pizza was my bread with cheese and tomato on it awakening. I swear to god pizza is the best food ever created. I can't stop eating pizza and it's got me kicked out of every pizza party ever. Apparently I'm supposed to "share" MY pizza with all these pizza CASUALS. Later on I tracked down Nyanwolf and Zombiecare and helped the song Don't Touch My Pizza get a following. We even got a skin in the worst roblox game, Forsaken! Then we made them remove it because the only thing they ever did that didn't suck was drop noli and they delayed him with new insanely detailed dev characters. Well I'll tell you I got to this one place and INSTANTLY knew I was

Great hidden gem in the quad city area on the Iron Range. Service was quick and friendly and the pizza was fantastic! I got the taco pizza and the crust was light fluffy and crunchy and the toppings were fresh. Great pizza sauce as well. Prices were reasonable. If you’re driving through the area this spot is well worth the detour!

The pizzas were perfect. Crisp but soft (?!) crust, the cheese was charred just enough, saucy without being too dangerous. I want these all the time. Should have asked for a side of ranch but they were still delicious without. We also had cheese curds and cinnamon-sugar bites with cream cheese frosting. Not a miss in the meal.

This was a very popular pizza place several years back, then has been closed since last year. We are happy to see it opened again. The pizza isn't quite as good as wecremember, but we think the Newtownards just need time to perfect the recipe and baking. It eas a bust nightvwhen we went in to order and they expedited our order so we didn't have to wait long.

Stopped in to order carry out on a Friday around 5pm. The guy working the front counter seemed overwhelmed and took two phone orders that called in after I had been standing at the counter for several minutes. Was told it was going to be 60+ minutes for carry out so I asked to have it delivered to the hotel. The pizza showed up in 30 minutes to my surprise and was generally a good pie with the sauce being on the peppery side. Single topping large pizza delivered was $20 and I tipped the driver 25% for fast delivery. Happy bellies, thank you.