Pop-Pop's NY Pizza

This spot may be hard to find, but it’s so worth it! Definitely a hidden gem! Family and locally owned for over 5 years, they specialize in Italian and Mexican cuisine. The Sicilian pizzas are DEFINITELY a must try! They are huge with a nice dough soft with lots of cheese! The affogato is one of the fanciest and tastiest that I have had! They do heart shaped pizzas all year round and have multiple kinds of Mexican pizza to try as well! New York Vibes flourish here and all the food is made with love!

Used to really enjoy this place a few years back in particular the Mexican menu. Felt like the ingredients were always fresh and homemade. The last few times we have ordered both nachos and quesadillas had sliced American cheese that was not even melted I guess they don't have shredded cheese but obviously this one component ruins the dishes.

The pizza is good but the girl who takes my order is unpleasant. I get it’s a family place so she doesn’t probably stress out too much about customer service. But being nice goes a long way and makes the food taste better.

Was really hopeful about this pizza. Flavor was good, but the crust on the "thin crust" Sicilian was too tough to chew. Not crispy or burnt. It was just kind of stale and was hard to rip through. My wife said the crust was too hard to chew. We're going to try to reheat later to see if it'll crisp up. HUGE garlic knots which we enjoyed. It was a friday night at 8:30, so we'll try another day and time for the next pie.

We went there with grandkids who were very excited to go. The whiole family loves everything about Pop Pops. Whether it’s delivery or dine in, we’re never disappointed. Support this small business. Your taste buds will thank you.