Pudgie's Pizza, Pasta & Subs - Vestal

I've tried to go back at least twice since I left the original review, every time the pizza looked so old and disgusting I didn't even bother. If you look through the reviews, this appears to be a VERY common problem here. Original Review: The pizza here is decent, not great, not terrible, kind of a local spin on a fast food pizza like Pizza Hut or Dominos. That being said I do stop in for slices fairly regularly because they are conveniently located to me. I’d recommend you stay vigilant when ordering slices though, I was in recently and ordered a slice of pepperoni, despite there being a fresh pizza in the case with 3 or 4 slices taken out of it already, they gave me one of two ancient, dried up looking, old slices that they had in the case. I’m not sure why others were deemed worthy of

We ordered a deep dish pizza and wings for pick up. It was so easy to pick up via the drive thru window, ready when promised, and delicious!

We love going to pudgies whenever we are in town. We were at the vestal location the counter guy was great I don't remember his name I know he's from Montrose, he greeted us as soon as we entered, he was engaging and helpful. It's great to see in this day and age. service work is a difficult job and this young man makes it look easy.

Pudgie's is good and consistent with their food quality and taste. My mom usually doesn't prefer to eat pizza , she asked me to order Pudgie's veggie pizza the second time (after tasting it the first time a week ago), she said it's pretty good, that's it... and that all😎😀

Food was great, we got onion rings & a couple of cheese steak sandwiches. Some of the best onion rings ever. Everything was made fresh & very hot when it came to the table. Workers were extremely nice.