Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

We stopped in n on 10/18/25 to get a mango gelati and a vanilla custard cone and a concrete. Mango gelati next to no flavor of mango, the custard tastes of way to much heavy cream not much flavor. 1st trip to the window gave me a strawberry gelati to it back again ask for mango, my mango again taste of little next to nothing as well ice was very thick, custard on top fell to the floor and this cup(lg) was filled to the top with ice no custard in between 3rd trip to window finally got it made right. Again not much mango taste. Mango Gelati is the only I get!!! So refreshing.

We stood outside and got the multiple layered mango gelati. The store is placed really conveniently and a good place to go to when it's hot. I hope to go back and try other menu options before the summer ends.

Rita's is a family favorite, been coming here for years! Rich, creamy custard on top of flavored Italian ice. My favorites are the root beer and the cherry, each with vanilla custard. Amazing!

The Rita’s in my town closed, so whenever I’m in Carlisle, I try to stop in if I’m not too full from eating brunch or dinner elsewhere. Today was the perfect day for the large gelati with root beer ice! So yummy. And the guy at the counter was very nice-even said to have a nice evening ! The people in front of me got some custard for their dogs because they were eating that when I arrived. So I guess they have pup cups too!

I ordered the Mango-Peach sugar -free Italian ice with DoorDash. The Dasher literally dropped off my order at a random house and then told me to call DoorDash support. I just had surgery and haven’t eaten in almost 3 months. I can only have clear liquids or sugar free popsicle or Italian ice. As long as I can tolerate it! I was so overwhelming disappointed that the dasher didn’t do his job. I called Rita’s and explained to the manager Taylor what had happened. Taylor then assured me she would make sure the next door dash gets to me and they did! To my surprise the manager at Rita’s (Taylor) also wrote me a note with my order from her and her employee. It’s the little things that count! And I can’t express how grateful I am for this locations act of kindness. Thank you so much. This will fo