Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

We ordered a Greek salad and cheese pizza. They forgot the dressing and there was no sauce on the pizza. When I called about the lack of dressing they offered me a $1 credit. Às far as the sauce, we ended up heating our own sauce and putting it on top. We will never go back to this Salvatore’s again.

Amazing Pizza! Haven't had pizza this good in a while! Really hit the spot after cycling from Lockport to Brockport along the Erie Canal. Grazie Louie! 😀🍕 Highly recommended!

This is $6 worth of onions rings ? I called what was apparently a busy time , they said it would be 45-1 hour wait . When I picked up the food it was lukewarm at best . The onion rings are cold and pathetic. 2 subs and an order of onions rings almost $40. First and very last time I’ll be going here .

Directions: .coming from Main Street. This one is a very easy to find. Especially from the Erie Canal. Does sit back a little, but you know you are very close when at the canal. Now, if you are coming from route, 104 heading south on route 19 (Main Street), there is the a roundabout part. Make sure to head south and passing by Pizza Hut and Dollar General. Salvatore’s is on the right side. There is a small area to park; however, on the other side there is more parking available. Now if you are coming route 31. Heading north on Route 19. Passing by several lights and this does include downtown Brockport. Now once you have reached the canal bridge. You would go over the bridge the building is on the left side. Take your time during the winter time; because, that will be your turning left are

Not at all impressed. Terrible signage. I parked in a handicap spot next to the Salvatore car. Walked toward a door, but it’s only drivers. Told to around. Opened my simple turkey sub with a few toppings…they’re chinchy on the food and toppings. It was Wrapped sloppily. Ripped packaging causing food to fall out. It was not cut in 4 as I requested. Bread feels/tastes stale. I will not ever go to this store again