Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

The smell when we came in was so amazing, and we soon figured out why! From the app (we had the pesto cheese bread) to the two pizzas (Margherita & Crazy Italian) we narrowed our choice down to- the meal was superb! Service was friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere was soft and cozy Great visit! We’ll be back!

The adults had a 12" taco pizza and the kids had 7" cheese and sausage pizzas. The pizza toppings were really good but the crust didn't have a lot of flavor. Quick service, checking in on us as needed.

I love pizza,. I’ve had a lot of pizza at many different places in my 66 trips around the sun. I had the Crazy Italian pizza at Sammy’s tonight.. It was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. In addition to the great food, the service was excellent and the atmosphere was cozy, despite being a little stark. I am anxious to go back and try some of their other menu items.

Had supper here twice during my travels through Green Bay in June 2025. Outstanding Service and Delicious Food. The owner suggested several meals on the menu and I experienced a pizza recommendation and a pasta recommendation, which were both amazing. Excellent portions at a fair price. The teamwork concept of all servers helping each other was unique and exceptional. Definitely will eat here again!

Delicious homemade Italian comfort food! Meatballs and sausage A++ From 2 Italians, this is just like grandma made! Highly recommend, also very reasonably priced, we both had pasta. Didn't have the pizza, that's for next time!