Sam's Pizzeria

New owners first time here since Asked for fried got it baked, asked for toppings got nothing, undercooked, cold just terrible all I. All Terrible I’m writing this review while at dinner table with plate infront of me. And I asked for pep, bacon, feta and hot pepper and I think I only got pep and not very much of anything inside.im very disappointed and I don’t think I’ll be going back here ever again definitely not the same SAM’S as it once was 😢 I’m highly disappointed and your lucky I was stopped from (returning) coming back with all my food. And to the cook how can you put this together and be okay with it you need a new job maybe a greeter bc you should not be allowed back in the kitchen if you can’t make a easy panzerotti

Wow! Sam’s has left me speechless! This past week I visited Windsor to see my boyfriend and he said we have to go to Sam’s. I was hesitant at first due to not loving pizza or anything similar to it, but was I ever amazed! The specials, all the dishes, and drinks were delicious! I look forward to going back! Also big shout out to Spencer and Andrew for ensuring our visits were spectacular every time! As well as the owner! I came back to visit and again! Another amazing experience! To top it off, Spencer made me the most delicious espresso martini!

We visited for lunch on a Saturday in November. We were the only ones there. The sign said new management. The atmosphere was great- old building with rustic decor interesting art. I liked it. The garlic cheese bread was amazing. My daughter got chicken strips and fries and the rest of us got pizza. It was very good. The crust was thin, which we l like. The toppings were high quality. We would definitely visit again.

From the minute we walked in, it looked like a ghost town. My daughter & I were the only customers this late afternoon. This once busy happening pizzeria has certainly taken a hit with it's new owners. I was quite disappointed that no alcohol was to be served. Could have used a nice cold pint with our pizza. Especially with the big screen TV showing a football game. The young man serving us was quite pleasant. The Sam's Special Pizza was as great as I remembered. Flavourful sauce & crust with plenty of toppings. But overall, because of the lack of ambiance for an Italian pizzeria & the absence of a liquor license, I gave it only two ⭐ ⭐ The restaurant is now an empty shell of what it once was. I would not return to dine in, however I wouldn't hesitate to order out if I'm ever back in that

Pizza is still good and the server was nice, however the other recent reviews are spot on about the atmosphere. The changes to the interior are incredibly strange and off putting, with harsh lighting and bland decor. Removing alcohol was clearly a huge mistake, as there was nobody else in the restaurant while we were eating. Unlikely to dine in again, this is now take out only as far as I’m concerned.