Sellands Neighborhood Cafe & Bar Broadway

Very nice neighborhood market cafe to dine with family and friends throughout the week! Even eating alone is nice as well! Dog friendly and very casual home like atmosphere with a nice ambiance! The staff is fast and friendly and the Food is Excellent! So Yummy and Fresh! Never Disappointed when I come here! Good Vibes! 🥰

The atmosphere is great! The food is just okay, not to mention how expensive it is, $35 for lunch... I ordered truffle mushroom pizza and was excited about it, but it was so greasy that was just unappetizing. Beet salad was good but not for $8, I wouldn’t order it again. Would I come back? Only for the atmosphere, not the food because the price vs taste is disappointing

2nd visit: Gave it another try bc friends wanted to meet here. This time, staff was friendly. Still, I did not enjoy my salmon "nicoise" salad. It was served in a dirty dish (pls wipe-down). Salad was oily, which ruined the blanched green beans for me. No dressing flavor, just oil pooling in my bowl. Small bowl had at least 6 whole garlic cloves in it, which is excessive. I did give this honest feedback to the staff, so maybe they will fix the recipe in the future. Then the drip coffee pot was cleared away before I could get a refill. Do I have the worst luck here or is this place overhyped? 1st visit: A letdown. I heard so many good things. Was excited to try a salad and the famous sandwich cookie. To start, decor is suburban farmhouse chic. Counter service was friendly, but also slow an

Really enjoyed the food and atmosphere of this place. Very friendly bartender that makes great drinks and a very spicy bloody Mary per my request.

They have become lackluster. We used to come here once a month for the last few years. Now it’s like every 5 months because their quality in pizza has diminished a great deal. Barely any cheese or sauce. Sad because it’s been so good for a few years. Even their power ceaser salad which is cheap for them became a power ice berg. Ridiculous.