Sheepshead Baygels

Each time I order from this place I try to give them the benefit of the doubt that they either won’t mess up my order or maybe I’ll get a quality bagel. I’m wrong each and every time. Gave them a break for a while, ordered from them again today for the first time in a while and what I received is not what I ordered. I ordered an everything bagel with cream cheese and bacon. They send a plain bagel with cream cheese. It also seems like they use whatever cream cheese was left on the knife from the previous order they made and put that little amount onto the next bagel order. Skimping on cream cheese is at a bagel store is horrible. They bagels were never good to begin with they’re tiny and seem like they shrink each time I’m dumb enough to order from them thinking maybe this time it’ll be wo

Spent $40 on a dozen bagels at 7:30 in the morning. They just opened so the bagels should be hot and fresh. Not at all. Cold and hard as a rock left over from the day before. What a disappointment. Never again

More of a deli than a bagel shop FOOD - Bagels were hard very dense and very tough. Early morning visit so they were not old but had a not fresh taste. Very tough. No everything seasoning on top of bagel and a little on the bottom which was strange. Pork roll was sliced nicely. Pork roll was good. Lunch may have been better here. The toasted bagel was barely toasted. Toasted on the grill, I think they don’t have a toaster which is strange for a bagel place. SERVICE - service was fine. No other customers so it was quick. Atmosphere/location - definitely felt more like a deli than a bagel shop. atmosphere was not great it was dark and slow. Right off 35 and easy to get in with plenty of parking.

The best bagel in the area hands down. Has a nice crisp outside and soft inside, the BEC is a masterpiece. Everyone in the shop is super friendly and you feel like you’re part of a family. If you want a bagel that tastes like you got it in Brooklyn hands down this is the place.

Classic Pork roll, egg, and cheese on a bagel. Reduced one star for smaller bagel options, 10 styles or so. Baker's dozen for $18 is more than fair. Great quality, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Cash only and very limited coffee options. Bring your own travel mug, so hot you might get burned with their cup. Old School Jersey service, great experience.