Sicilian Delight

There's no shortage of good food in Ithaca, but I will stand on business that they have the best pizza. I go out of my way to eat here if I can when I feel like having pizza. I've never had bad food from here and the staff are amazing. They deserve all of the business.

The food was pretty good. I got a cheese pizza. Nice crust, a bit too cheesy for my liking. The tables were a bit dirty-but that isn’t the pizza places fault! The server was great, fast, nice, and let us take the shakers to our table. The atmosphere wasn’t great, as it is in the middle of a very dead mall. Overall pretty good pizza for a mall, I would go again. Attached are a photo of a pizza and two combos.

Sicilian Delight has to be the best Pizza in Ithaca and some of the best quality in general. Stefano is a fantastic owner just super humble and kind to everyone. He makes all his food with patience and love. He brings Brooklyn pizza here in its most authentic form. Highly recommend this gem!

Highly disappointed in this visit. Friendly staff but the pizza and wings were not up to the usual standard we have had before. Our pizza was supposed to be pepperoni and luckily we caught that it was only cheese before we left and they fixed it. We asked for well done but it was soggy and not great. The wings felt like they were microwaved and barely had sauce on them plus they didn’t come with any blue cheese. $50 for a pizza and wings already feels pricy and then when it’s not what you were exacting it feels extra ridiculous. Probably our last visit for a while because something feels like it’s changed.

Splendid place! A clean, neat restaurant. A stellar selection of very unique Italian food at good prices. Friendly, hospitable staff. Stefano and Josh did great jobs taking care of me. Highly recommended!