Sidewall Pizza Company

Had a terrible experience. I placed take out order that had one hour time. I got there a few minutes early. I got in the pick up line and waited over half an hour. The guy running things seemed overwhelmed . A few different times, he came out to the line and asked people their names and would ask a bunch of people, but didn’t write anything down he was trying to remember as he went to the back. After almost 30 minutes past my quoted pick up time I asked had my food been put in the oven yet and he said no. The frustrating part is had I got there and they said we’re running 1 to 2 hours behind quoted times no problem but waiting there for over 30 minutes and getting almost no acknowledgment and then me having to ask was it even in the oven, which it wasn’t, is frustrating. Did not get a gift

Excellent restaurant, and underrated by the reviews. Been coming here since they opened, and they’ve always had consistent great service, very good food, and good atmosphere. My wife and I love the salads, and kids love the pizzas (Greenville Goddess is a unique favorite, and all are good) and bread sticks. Personally I think the sauce could use a little more “umph” to my taste (unsure what type of tomatoes they use, and/or a little fresh basil and tiny amount of fresh garlic maybe?), but that’s a very minor nit-pick from this former New Yorker. I don’t expect Brooklyn or New Haven Pizza in the upstate, and this is one of the better pizzas in the upstate. The service is particularly what keeps us coming back.

Sidewall is a family favorite! Their gluten-free pizzas are insanely good - you can get virtually any pizza made on gluten-free crust! We've never had an issue with cross-contamination. They do a great job ensuring gluten-free eaters can enjoy their meal. The gluten-free breadsticks are a real treat, too! Save room for ice cream (my favorite is the vegan chocolate)!

Sidewall pizza had become a staple in our house hold! The mushroom pizza is out of this world! I tried the pesto antipasto pizza, and the flavors were great, however it is very heavy on the pesto, so if you like pesto this is a great option for your. The server was very friendly and tended to our table perfectly. The only fault I have with this location is the inside seating is tight quarters, it was way too cold and windy to set on their porch/patio and inside seating is cramped.

We are regulars at the Simpsonville on Main. We always order pizza with DOUBLE mushroom. Today we ordered our usual pizza and a wedge salad. There were mushrooms for a single order pizza. Major disappointment. The salad was not what we usually see. It was very small and the lettuce was not as fresh as it should be. I took a picture of it for reference.