Simply Natural Creamery Morehead City

Nice selection of flavors on 5/16/25 visit. 2 gals behind the counter were working hard as store was very busy. Ice cream was good and also got a 1/2 gallon of chocolate milk that was awesome

Simply Natural Creamery offers a fantastic variety of ice creams that truly stand out. The banana split is a must-try; it's definitely the best item on the menu with its perfect blend of flavors and generous toppings. However, I did find the milkshakes to be a bit on the smaller side for the price you pay. Overall, it's a great spot for ice cream lovers, but just keep in mind the portion sizes for the milkshakes!

The ice cream is incredible! They have a great selection of fun flavors. They also make delicious milkshakes and gourmet sundaes. They also offer delicious chocolate milk and butter!

I'll start by saying the inside of this place looks awesome. My boyfriend got a cookies and cream milkshake. I guess they used too much milk because it was basically a cup of milk with barely any cookie chunks as they had all been crushed into dust pretty much. It poured out of the cup and into the trashcan like water. I got 2 scoops of double dark chocolate ice cream and it had barely any flavor. We spent $14 and both threw ours away and went to cook out for milkshakes. Way better quality milkshake there.

Excellent flavored ice cream . High quality ice cream. I had Salty Caramel. Absolutely delicious. My husband had Twix Ice cream. Very good also. Serving were generous. Staff friendly and helpful. Definitely recommend to friends and we will be back when in the area. Highly recommend this ice cream!!