Smithtown Bagels Inc

Picture speaks for itself. BURNT BACON… and yet, someone decided it was still a good idea to put it in the sandwich. This will be the first and last time here. There are plenty of other bagel places in the area that actually take pride in what they serve.

Lovely to find a bagel place that has vegan cheese. People are super friendly and they go out of their way to walk you through the options. Fillings are fresh and the bagel comes with a great texture that is easy to digest. The shop is very well decorated and it’s so easy to see how beloved these folks are in the community! Definitely going back!

First time coming here and it might be my last. My order was quite simple. Plain bagel, egg, and cheese. When my order came out it was a fried egg on a plain bagel. When I sent it back, what I received was a bagel with scrambled egg and no cheese. I understand that mistakes happen but when it does it a second mistake shouldn't follow.

Been going here for years. This is my absolute go-to bagel place on LI. As a matter of fact, any time I show a non-native what LI bagels taste like, I bring them here. The bagels are always super fresh. The sandwiches are delicious. The people working there are either family, or like family, as they communicate really well, and the whole thing runs like a well-oiled machine. Everyone is friendly, efficient at their jobs, and great to chat with when the line isn't super long. Love this place. And if they ask "salt peppa ketchup", ya gotta try it at least once. Looking forward to going back again soon, this is absolutely the best bagel joint on LI.

These guy are one of my favorite places to get breakfast. The grill skill are great, cooked perfectly Omelettes are nice and big. The crew is like family