Sonny & Tony's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Ordered through DoorDash. They send their own guy who couldn’t find my address. Delivered an ice cold pie and when I called for a refund they said sorry it’s through DoorDash. BUYER BEWARE. I’ve eaten here for years. Never again. Why use DoorDash if you’re going to send your own delivery guys? Scam

Love the food here,friendly staffand can bring the family here plus inexpensive. Update just went back here last night food is so good love the pizza.update just had a delivery from here got a personal pizza with extra cheese it arrived on time and it was in perfect condition the cheese didn't slide off the pizza .When I get it at other places always find it is a mess cheese all over the place except the pie.Great job Sonn and Tony's a the delivery man.udate 4 /26/23 Had a delivery made pizza very good but they have to cut the pit better this isn't the first time had this issue trouble pulling apart and finding where one slice ends and one begins. Other than that pizza was delicious.

Amazing food and amazing service. Every time I’m here they are amazing. It’s the best Italian food/ pizzeria in Mahwah. Must try the chicken parm sandwich.

Update September 2022: Without warning they stopped honoring and participating in the pizza points on the slice app. However, you still need to order the pizza off slice and pay the local fees without any benefit. Unfortunately I have 7 pizza points and needed one more for a free pizza. I accepted that they needed to raises prices on their menu and I continued to order, but this is one more way to alienate and be cheap towards loyal customers. You’ve lost my business of purchasing weekly, what a shame, but shame on you. Pizza is the best I’ve had in this area. The wings are very good but could be sauced a little more. Garlic knots are tasty. The speed of the takeout can get a little long at times but the staff are friendly and work hard.

I moved out of NJ 7+ years ago, but every time I visit, Sonny and Tony’s makes the go-to list. I get the stuffed rigatoni vodka and a cappuccino for dessert, and am never disappointed. They’ll be a favorite for life! Also love that it’s BYOB.