St. Augie's Pizza

We were looking for pizza by the slice. We had seen St. Augies Pizza while on a tour. We ordered a slice and drink for dinner. Very reasonable in price. The pizza crust was incredible tasting. The pizza was fresh tasting and the pepperoni was delicious. I highly recommend seeking them out for a quick meal.

If you’re looking for true New York–style pizza with that authentic, family-owned feel, this is the place. (I'm so happy to live just a few blocks away from this gem) From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere hits you — it’s got that real NY vibe. No gimmicks. No over-the-top décor. Just that classic, welcoming, neighborhood pizzeria energy that instantly makes you feel at home. You can tell it’s the real deal. Now let’s talk about the pizza. Absolutely amazing. The crust is everything you want in a true NY slice — perfectly crisp on the outside, soft and foldable on the inside, with that slight chew that makes it authentic. The sauce has incredible flavor without being overpowering, the cheese is perfectly balanced, and every bite tastes fresh and made with pride. You can tell they ca

Now THATS a slice!!! Hands down the best pie in St John’s County. Everything tastes fresh. Crispy flavorful crust. Great gravy/sauce. And great vibe. It’s just about the pie. 😊. Closest you will get to NYC in the county. We LOVE it!!!

St. Auggie’s Pizza was an okay experience, but not one that really stood out. The pizza itself had good flavor, but unfortunately it was overcooked, which took away from the overall enjoyment. The crust was harder than expected and made the slices less satisfying. The service also left something to be desired. The staff wasn’t particularly friendly or welcoming, and interactions felt rushed rather than attentive. While the place has potential, the combination of unfriendly service and overcooked pizza made the visit feel underwhelming. It wasn’t a terrible experience, but it also wasn’t memorable in a positive way. With a bit more care in food preparation and customer service, Auggie’s Pizza could be much better. Will not return.

Quiet little pizza spot with great prices and a family feel to it. Pizza was mouth watering and the fantastic pricing made it impossible to not grab another slice. Terra was welcoming and made us some fresh knots that left us feeling rejuvenated. Definitely will be coming back!