Stemie's 1818 Tavern

The bartender "Kelly" was excellent! The food tasted good and the drinks were very good! It is a small to medium place. It's not too loud and the atmosphere is cozy! Good place to bring date or significant other to have a relaxing good time.

Food and service were excellent. Nice place for lunch or dinner prices very reasonable only complaint tables small and close together a little tight in there.

1818 Tavern is a fantastic spot to visit! We stopped by for drinks and were impressed by the atmosphere—both calming and lively for a Thursday night. There were plenty of tables available, and we chose to sit at the bar. I ordered two martinis, which were simple but very tasty. The bartenders and staff were attentive, friendly, and ensured our orders were taken care of promptly. We didn’t try the food, but we will definitely be returning to try what they have on the menu. It would be a cute date night idea to grab some tasty drinks or to just go out with friends. Overall, a great experience!

Let me lead with the fact that this would be a 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 review were it not for one issue with the crab cakes. As you will see on the photo of the menu their crab cakes are supposed to be made with ONLY lump crab meat. I normally double check with the wait staff, but because only was underlined I did not. I was sorely dissatisfied when I got the crab cake and as you will also see in my photo it was 100% shredded crab meat. This is not unlike going to a steakhouse and ordering a filet mignon only to have it brought out as ground beef. Please be warned to confirm beforehand if the crab cakes are truly lump or shredded even though the menu insists they are lump. The remainder of the review is all very positive. The atmosphere was quaint. The service was excellent. The food was exceptional. The sh

Awesome list of martinis here!!! I didn’t take a photo but they have two lists, one white and one red and I believe 70 total. Food was fantastic. Crab au gratin was amazing!!! Service by Kristen was terrific.