Steve's Pizzeria & More

Food is a little pricey compared to other places. Food is good and was delivered quickly and still hot. We got chicken tender dinner and a Rueben with a side of fries. The only thing is I wish there was a way on the online ordering to add an extra side of dressing. It said extra and side but I didn’t know if that meant on the sandwich or totally off the sandwich.

Updating my review 2024: really good Greek style pizza. You wouldn’t know it as green pizza per say but tasty when ‘done well’ and not burnt. The women there were very sweet. Unfortunately still no ApplePay and we didn’t have our credit card :-( good thing I know my card number. 2023: Decent pizza on the Cape. Not as good as Jack’s or Paul’s in my opinion, but another good option. Unfortunately, they don’t have a marinara pizza and didn’t charge less for no cheese but made the best of it with some veggies on mine. They were pleasant and we waited about 20 min for pick-up. There is seating indoors and they accept cash/cc. You gotta try all the pizza places to find your favorite, so try Steve’s and see for yourself!

Best Eggplant Parmesan sub I have ever tried. I added grilled onions, mushrooms, garlic and banana peppers from the online order checklist. The large sub is huge, I saved half for tomorrow. My husband enjoyed his meatball parmesan sub also.

Fantastic pizza whether you’re looking to bring some back for the family, or even stop by while exploring the town and being touristy. This is my second visit in two days, and neither visit was to disappoint. They have a wide variety of options to order, however I love the pepperoni pizza too much to change my mind next time. Big thanks to the folks running this establishment, massively recommend Steve’s Pizzeria while anyone’s in town or even driving through!

Decent pizza nothing special. The restaurant was outdated and the bathroom was EXTREMELY dirty and even had blood stains on the wall