Strathmore Bagels

Last place in the three village area you can still get a DELICIOUS bagel for a decent price. No idea why they’re only at 3.9 stars. Let’s get it up.

Another awesome bagel breakfast sandwich 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 they even had cute bin of holiday coloring stuff w crayons and we loved sitting looking out window at counter 🫶🏼

They need new management or something. Almost an hour wait for a roll with bacon and egg. Manager or owner from what I gathered, closed the kitchen door bc he got overwhelmed with staff telling him anything. (Professional) When I went up to place the order I was told 10min. originally. It’s not like this is the only time they’ve done this either, the last few times I’ve gone they’ve straightup lied about wait times yet still take your money. Either stop taking so many orders or be honest about the wait. Does this sandwich look like it should take an hr to make?

They got my order wrong TWO times. I asked for a lox scallion cream cheese bagel. The first time I just got scallion cream cheese. The second time they put salmon cream cheese. I am a native English speaker and spoke clearly, left no room for confusion, but they still tried to gaslight me into thinking I made it seem confusing. “Lox poppy seed bagel with scallion cream cheese.” Please clean out your ears ☺️

If you are in the Stonybrook/Lake Grove area and you haven’t been here - you absolutely should try it out! I come here often and today I was craving a classic Bacon, Egg & Cheese Sandwich and as always - Nailed it 👏🏻 AMAZING STAFF - they are the nicest people ever, even under stressful situations they are always accommodating and polite! Be patient with them when they are busy, because they are truly wonderful people and they do an incredible job! I’d give them 6 stars if I could! Thank you for always making my experience here pleasant and delicious 🫶🏻