Taste of New York Fayetteville

👍🏾I live behind this & never tried it until today. The food fresh, hot & was very good. Quality ingredients. Menu priced about average this category with other places. 30min & ready on time. We expected slightly larger Strombolis - little disappointed. At Mom & pops I’ve had bigger for similar price. Lunch gone, but for dinner i should’ve got a side The steak Stromboli was finely diced meat onion & pepper- all smaller than you would for spaghetti. The veggie spaghetti was a big portion 👎🏾Deceptive billing system online orders. 36$ after tax with promo (it was 39$ after tax & fees with NO promo which did NOT include the unexplained new total with an extra $1.xx ). After you confirm your total with tax & fees you would expect the receipt, but no- there’s a tiny paragraph about your order no

First time trying A Taste of NY on Cliffdale and it did not disappoint! I ordered takeout and got a Stromboli and pizza, and both were fantastic. The supervisor/owner and staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming when I came in to pick up my order. Great food, great service, and a great first impression. Will definitely be coming back.

First time trying this location on Cliffdale, absolutely love the one on Raeford... went out of my comfort zone & ordered 12 wings since I usually only get pizza and chicken parm from Raeford. I wont lie, I was a lil disappointed. I got 2 flavors, the sweet chili & mango habanero, at 1st they looked juicy & good in size, but definitely lacked flavor, meat was dry & it was too hard to chew in some areas. For the price of the 12 wings... it would of been nice it came with a small side of fries or even the usual celery & carrot sticks, like most other places who offer wings. The lady at the front taking the order was the sweetest & other employees seem great, but probably will never get wings from there again.

We had such a great experience at Taste of New York! From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere was welcoming and relaxed. The staff was friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed without being overbearing. The pizza was absolutely delicious, perfectly baked crust, flavorful sauce, and generous toppings. You can tell the ingredients were fresh, and everything tasted made-to-order. The cheese had that perfect stretch, and every bite was balanced and satisfying. Service was quick, the restaurant was clean, and the overall vibe made it a place we’d definitely come back to. Whether you’re dining in with family or grabbing takeout, this spot is a solid choice. Highly recommend if you’re craving great pizza!

Oh my goodness!!!! The pizza was Amazing! Fresh and Unforgettable. The staff was friendly and welcoming. 10/10 ⭐ We will absolutely be returning. Thank you for making my Birthday lunch so wonderful!! 😊