Taverna 5450

This is a great place in Carroll Valley that I have enjoyed as a National Fire Academy attendee for the last 15 or so years. My wife and I recently had an enjoyable lunch that included their gyro and the crab cake sandwich. Neither disappointed! This restaurant is worth your time if you are in the area.

My friends and I came for a quick bite after visiting the library mountain resort. i ordered the hot honey chicken sandwich and fries. They serve bar- type food. We all thought it was delicious. The staff were great and welcoming as well. Would recommend if you’re in the area!

Tried this place tonight and we were really hoping to like it since we recently moved to the area and have been looking for good local spots to eat away from the tourist trap that is Gettysburg. The atmosphere felt a bit more like a dive bar than a tavern. Not a whole lot of decor or anything really visually interesting going on. The patio outside looked nice, so I'm sure that gets packed during warmer months. We ordered a couple appetizers that came out in a timely manor. The reuben balls were over-fried and lacked the balance of flavors of a good reuben, i.e. missing that tang from a decent amount of saurkaut, and presentation was messy with the sauce just plopped right down on the plate. Crab dip was decent and was a good-sized portion. Gyro was pretty good, burger was cooked well-done

Definitely not a place i will try again. Exaggerating expensive for the food. Lettuce had brown spots, some fries were cold, burger was incorrectly cooked, some items we had to ask for several times, and gravy came when food was nearly ate. She said she was taking it off the bill but never did. The waitress was rude, inattentive, and super distracted. It was dirty, tables were unclean even after the waitress wiped it down missing a lot of it, tables are rusty, and seats are hard.

We had dinner at Taverna 5450 while we were in the Gettysburg area. We both ordered seafood dishes and they were both excellent. Service was great and friendly. The restaurant was busy and it was fairly noisy, but we sat in a booth and that helped. We would not hesitate to go back, if ever in the area again.