The Bakery

I’m in New Paltz all the time and have seen this place before, but I never tried it until my most recent trip. This place was so adorable, and I would definitely come back. The coffee was excellent, as was my bacon, egg, and cheese. The staff and service were great as well! The servers were so sweet and made sure my order was correct. I couldn’t be happier with my experience, and you best believe I’ll be back.

I’ve only had incredibly pleasant experiences at The Bakery until today. The staff are wonderful and amazing at their jobs, but the owner clearly has no clue what she is doing. I ordered a simple caramel latte and received something that was neither caramel nor a latte. I asked to have it remade only to find out that the “reason I didn’t like it” was because she didn’t even make that. She apparently added fudge?? She “fixed” it by adding more milk and caramel. It appears that she doesn’t know what a latte is because it was most likely a poorly drawn shot of espresso in a cup of stale black coffee with a splash of steamed milk. She is definitely aware of her lack of understanding as when I originally asked for a latte she looked frazzled and after she remade it she asked VERBATIM “is it al

Very cute bakery in New Paltz. Line was a bit long and we waited 30 mins but it was a Sunday morning & fresh food isn’t quick. My sandwich was a bit cold but after letting them a new fresh extra toasty sandwich was brought to me quickly a long with some complimentary cookies. Food was so yummy, coffee was delicious… lemonade was perfect. Definitely try the peanut butter cookie with chocolate on top.

Visited New Paltz for the first time and I could not be happier that this was the first place I walked into! The atmosphere was on point while the employees were helpful and sweet and came with some great recommendations! I believe Izzy served me and she was knowledgeable, kind and gave me a great experience! I’ll definitely be back!

I was amazed walking into this establishment. The immediate factor that made me decide to be a repeat customer was when I met Bella. Bella mesmerized me I had never tipped someone 50% before in my life and today was the day I realized that a business is only as good as the hard workers that create such an atmosphere… I will be back. Please, if you give them a raise you’ll make back the money ten fold in a week . Employee of the year.