The Blue Mahoe Restaurant

We had the fried shrimp. Excellent beer batter flavor but the sauce that comes with it has quite a bit of heat! If you're not into spicy, ask for tartar sauce! The beef empanadas were the bomb!

Restaurant seems to have another name on the door suggesting that it may be new owners. Anyway food was average but service extremely poor. Waited for a while for them to serve my large party and even though no body else was in restaurant they took forever to bring our meal which was preordered for my group. Didn’t bring water to all members of my party and never came back to refill our glasses. When they started bringing out the food they were so slow it felt like they were cooking each plate separately. Some of our party left because they couldn’t wait any longer to get there meals. Maybe the restaurant business is not for these people.

OMG one of the very worst food experiences I’ve ever had. My family arrived there for a repast after a funeral for a reservation we made weeks in advance yet they took over an hour before they started serving us and only brought out one meal at a time for a party of over 40 people. In the end many people had to leave without getting served. The food was average at best and did not taste like authentic Jamaican cuisine, then they brought some water to the table when we first arrived yet did not return to refill glasses so I had to go to the bar to buy a bottle of water just to get some water to drink (that’s how bad the service was). This restaurant does not deserve anything more than a one star rating and even that was generous.

Three Tides has all the makings of a great night—big setup, solid food, live music that carries the room. Inside feels dialed in, while outside, with its forgotten stage, begs for someone to care enough to finish the job. The hang-up was the service. Our waitress vanished mid-shift, and the handoff left the bills a mess—friends who’d already paid were accused of not paying, and we had to play detective to prove otherwise. Add in automatic gratuity tacked onto another group’s bill without clarity, and the whole thing got unnecessarily awkward. I don’t think it’s malice—just short staffing and sloppy process. But if they clean that up and give the outdoor stage the attention it deserves, Three Tides could be more than just good. It could be unforgettable.

Excellent. The Caribbean coleslaw is da bomb man! I love this side, but I’ve never had it like this. Sooooo good. The goat was G.O.A.T. Very laid back atmosphere, and extraordinarily friendly service. We visited on a Tuesday night before we had to travel to PA early the next morning, and left before the music started, but we’ll definitely be back