The Handsome Cab

Wow, where do I start? We visited the handesome cab Sat, Nov 15th, 2025. My wife and I were visiting York for the weekend. The owners were awesome, decor awesome, atmosphere awesome. Food, not so much!! Pretty terrible. My Cacio e Pepe was swimming in oil, the cheese was not creamy, it looked like the 3 cheeses were sprinkled on the dish without the constant blending into the pasta to create the creamy sauce, it was completely prepared incorrectly AND it came in a skillet!! It looked like oil and water seperating, clearly the chef has no clue how to make this simple, yet elegant, technical dish. My wifes main dish was the Portugeuse Burgerette.. The menu states it comes with an orange aioli but it clearly was not, it was mayonnaise, and lots and lots of it! Our appetizer consisted of the

Everything at The Cab is top notch. The food, the drinks, the service and the ambience. I never have had a bad experience. Robert and Andrew are amazing hosts. If you haven’t gone you’re missing out.

First, this place is so cute! The menu was a little different from what I usually see at places like this, but that made it a little bit fun and different. My husband and I met his sister and her husband here since we live a ways apart and York is a nice middle of the road meet up. The server was fine, but could have been a little more attentive. I ordered shrimp and grits. The entire dish was lukewarm warm at best. The grits were lumpy with large clumps of grits throughout. I can’t remember if there was 5 or six shrimp, but two of them were not deveined and they were over cooked. My brother-in-law ordered toast with his eggs, which he never got and the server never came back to check on. We won’t meet here again.

Well staffed with incredibly friendly and helpful staff! Food presentation was extraordinary as well as food quantity and quality! We really enjoyed our dinner! Huge variety of drinks and specials. Ambience was comfy, industrial, but elegant ! Highly recommend!!

This was a disappointment. Wanted to avoid the Valentine's holiday evening and have brunch the following morning instead. Chose The Handsome Cab for what looked to be an interesting brunch menu and good reviews. The atmosphere is the best thing this place has going. Its casual, some interesting decor and nice color scheme. The two most important things are lacking. The food and the service. We sat at the table for 1 hour before receiving food. Kitchen way too slow for the seating they have. Food was mediocre at best. Had hot honey fried chicken with french toast. Fried chicken was overcooked on the outside. Too dark and burnt in spots. Hot honey wasn't hot at all. Just sweet on sweet with some chicken. Micro greens on the plate for no reason at all other than trying too hard. My wife had b