The Island Fish Co. Restaurant & Tiki Bar

This place was TOP NOTCH!!! I'm an out of towner but I imagine locals even know how quality this place is. My wife and I both agreed that all of the food was some of the best that we've ever had. We both choose the "Catch of the Day" and opted to have the Hogfish, one stuffed and the other francaise. HANDSDOWN, THE BEST FISH THAT I'VE EVER HAD!!! As if the crab dip appetizer, the fresh salad and grouper bisque wasn't amazing, the entree was the king of the keys cuisine!!! Oh yeah, you haven't experienced key lime pie if it hasn't come from The Keys!!! From the drinks to the atmosphere to the food and gorgeous views, the value you get from it all is WELL worth the cost!!! The wait wasn't long at all, even showing up on an off-season weekend. The only downside is the parking but patience is

Parking can be difficult when busy at lunch and dinner, but not sure why? Food: was ok but not much spice or flavor, I guess if you like bland food and expensive drinks this is your place. Don't get me wrong the food was fine just not much taste. Service was good, got drinks quickly, food came in a reasonable time, waiter checked back a couple of times. Sitting right out next to the water with some shade is classic keys, and if you plan to camp out for the afternoon maybe that makes the food better. But we had things to do and it was in, easy lunch, and then put again. Give this review a like👍 or mark as helpful❤️ if you are still reading. Our hint is to order drinks and an app and hang out by the water but go eat dinner someplace else. Unless you had enough drinks them order here and

A popular spot for food and drinks in Marathon and just cross the street from the Fairfield by Marriott. We came in just past noon and didn’t have to wait but it does get busier and if you want to sit next to the water, you should try to avoid rush hours. Food was decent and my kids enjoyed it. We tried the fried key lime pie, but it was way too sweet and we all agree that a normal key lime pie would be better - in case you are curious about fired key lime pie on the menu! The atmosphere of the restaurant made me feel like i was swimming in the ocean and drinking a margarita - very refreshing decorations, very coastal and casual. Plenty of parking and decent food - I would recommend this place!

I want to start with our server…she was at our table seconds after we sat dawn to take our drink order, super attentive, and very friendly! Conch fritters were tasty and not heavy with filler. I was pleasantly surprised by the She Crab soup…it was chock full of delicious crab and the surprise factor was the coconut flavor. Main courses, fried shrimp & a grouper sandwich, were tasty! You get plenty of food, you will not leave hungry.

Excellent food, we had a mahi mahi sandwich that came with coleslaw, and a grouper, both delicious. Great looking and tasting cornbread and the rolls were highly addictive! Fun place to eat and watch sunset.