The Original PJ's Pizza - New Martinsville

Placed order ahead of time for 3:15 pickup. Got there at 3:17 and was told they forgot the boneless wings so give them 10 minutes. Go back inside at 3:27 and was told they forgot to put the sub in the oven and give them another 10 minutes. The order was not ready until 3:55 and based on the temperature of the food received I am not sure the story we were given was accurate. Everything was cold except the boneless wings (which I would expect to be cold if they were being made at 3:17 as indicated?) and the medium pizza in the order - even the sub was cold and that was one of the last things they said they needed to put in the oven? Disappointing to spend nearly $80 (and a tip that I'm now regretting) on 5 items for it to be 40 minutes late and cold. And initially I wasn't upset the text cod

Our pizza was phenomenal! They’re always loaded when you order, regardless of what size you get. The staff is always positive, even when they’re slammed! You can’t go wrong with this place!

Very friendly and quick service!! Great pizza and salad

The worst pizza I have ever had! The cheese wasn't melted thoroughly let alone browned and the crust was tough and chewy on the bottom and like a biscuit in the middle. I ordered an XL with 3X cheese and 3 toppings. It was almost $27 AFTER a $5 coupon for first time order online. It could POSSIBLY be DECENT at best if it was baked correctly. NEVER going back though! Stick to barristas for pizza in New Martinsville!!! Gonna be throwing the rest of this away. I TRIED but, YUCK!!! 🤢🤮😡 A total waste of money and time! Speedway pizza is better!

Two stars only because it’s edible and faster than buying a frozen pizza. The pizza is mostly bread, the sauce is bland, and the cheese could stand to be cooked a few minutes longer. I hate to recommend a major chain, but dominos is cheaper and better tasting.