The Pie Shell

Amazing pies! This place has a 4.8 rating and absolutely deserves it. These things are massive, delicious as heck, and always great. There's even the little touches, like a cherry shape cut into the top of the cherry pies. Superb. My coworker and I come up this occasionally for work, and we will make a point to each come and get one of these pies. Seriously, give one of these a try. You won't be disappointed.

Totally worth the drive from Tipp. The first thing we noticed upon entering is just how spotless the business is. It was beyond impressive! We’ve had quite a few of their desserts, and all were fresh and delicious. The chocolate peanut butter cupcakes and old fashioned custard pie are the standouts though. We brought their pumpkin pecan crumble pies to Thanksgiving last year, and everyone seemed to love them. We will definitely be back soon to try their peaches and cream. There’s no doubt it’ll be delicious as well.

This was some amazing pie! My girlfriend convinced her sister to get me something to congratulate me on a new job and this pie came about. I thought it looked beautiful but it looks equal exactly what the pie tastes like. Just a perfect peanut butter pie! I would enjoy this again and even look forward to seeing what other amazing things they have in store for me! Side note: I failed on taking a photo of the pie before we ate some because it looks so good I had to eat some immediately.

This place is obviously Susan's passion for many years. She gave me a quick tour of her inventory when I uttered I'd never been before. All the pies look adorable. I chose a blackberry, it was wonderful. I would get it again, look forward to the other flavors! They have cheesecakes too.

OUTSTANDING New York cheesecake! It made our special occasion dinner extra-special! Thank you Susan for setting one aside for me to pick up. Your passion and talent are obvious in your products and service!