The Pizzeria of Lake Grove

I just picked up two slices from The Pizzeria at Smith Haven Mall in Lake Grove, and they were absolutely delicious! The Sicilian slice was perfectly crispy with a great balance of sauce and cheese, and the Aunt Danielle slice with its creamy vodka sauce, cup & char pepperoni, stracciatella, fresh basil, and hot honey was an absolute game-changer—bursting with flavor! Huge shoutout to the cook, Anthony, for crafting such amazing slices. I'll definitely be back for more!

Me and my husband come here literally every other Friday, the pizza always fresh and delicious. My favorite is their Buffalo slice with a side of ranch. They also have different deals which is great we get the two specialty slices and a drink for set price.

Great service and great pizza. Made this pie fresh. Four different speciality slices. So good, Thanks Fellas

The pizza is amazing at the Pizzeria of Lake Grove. Anthony was very knowledgeable about his slices and he definitely helped me pick a good one. I tried a crumbled sausage with vodka sauce! Yummy. They had amazing choices of slices even when I was leaving the mall at the end of the night. I can't wait to come back and try something else!

I’ve lived in NY my whole life and this is still the best pizza I’ve had :) We obligatorily get the buffalo garlic knots and “tricolor” pizza slice (pesto vodka and tomato sauce) every time we shop here. Today, we came just for the pizza, didn’t even shop! Highly recommend you try at least once, you’ll want it every time