The Pizzeria of Smithtown

⭐⭐⭐⭐ Review for The Pizzeria of Smithtown My husband’s favorite appetizer is calamari, and it definitely didn’t disappoint. We loved it. The pizza was also really good, and the ambiance is relaxing, making it a great spot for family dinners or a casual date night. Service was friendly and attentive. The cacio e pepe was a bit too salty for our taste, but overall it’s a solid place to enjoy pizza and appetizers. As a local content creator, I enjoy checking out different spots around Long Island, and this is a nice option for a laid-back night out. 🍕✨

What a great visit! I was expecting a typical pizzeria vibe but this is anything but. They installed a doorway that blocks out the wind and called so guests aren't freezing. Then there's a nice sized dining room with bar. After that you will find the counter and self serve tables. Excellent service and great food.

My daughter and I go here regularly. It’s fantastic. The pizza is great and the dinners are even better. The people are friendly and it’s a great atmosphere. Highly recommended.

We absolutely love this pizzeria. The staff is always so kind and accommodating, which truly makes a difference. On our most recent visit, there was a small mistake with our order, and they corrected it immediately without hesitation and even removed it from the bill. My husband has celiac disease, and they consistently take such great care to ensure his food is safe and handled properly. It’s rare to find a place that’s both delicious and genuinely attentive. We’re always happy to come back!

first time being here and overall enjoy led the service and food, the staff is extremely friendly and the inside is very clean with ample seating for large parties. There was also a large garage door that can open for access next to the bar. I got a white slice and chicken parm both pretty decent