Theo's Midtown

I can’t even explain how good this place is! We had a make your own pizza, meatball appetizer and a cheese filled breadstick. We are from NY and this might be one of the best pizzas we’ve ever tasted!! Meatballs were season perfectly and the breadsticks were so tender and delicious. Thank you for an amazing meal!!

We are locals and we love this restaurant. Best pizza in town in our opinion. Greek style. Sandwiches are also great, and I am not a huge sandwich fan. Theirs is flavorful and fresh. Gyros are another favorite of ours. Try the Agean Plate appetizer, comes with the most amazing pita chips. You'll be hooked! Place is always clean, nice full bar, staff is welcoming. They get busy, and there's a good reason for that. Not cheapest place in town, but well worth it. Try them! Eat local!

We ate an early dinner on Saturday. Our server was wonderful and attentive. We enjoyed the Theo's special pizza with Greek sauage, and mushrooms. The House salad was very tasty. Penna with Maranara sauce was delicious. We will be back!

First time visiting based upon son’s recommendation. He takes after me, so he has excellent taste :). Absolutely great meal and lovely waitress, Maddie (make sure to ask her about how the pizzas are cooked, she provides in depth info!). Started with Pesto Chips which were delicious! Got a half Brooklyn, half Niki pizza. Both flavors were outstanding! Try it, you’ll love it.

Restaurant with a sports bar atmosphere. Great service and the meatball appetizer was so delicious. We ordered a gyro and pepperoni & sausage calzone with fries as a side. All of the food was really good, hubby says sausage had a really good taste in the calzone. It wasn't the best gyro I've had but it was good. Fries were also very good, crunchy with seasoning. We ordered a Greek-style pizza to go. Unfortunately, the crust was cracker-like and not our favorite. We'll definitely stop again for the meatballs!