Times Square Pizza Co

Ordered a specialty pizza with half jalapeno and half banana pepper and got a pizza with ONLY jalapeno and banana pepper. Went back to get the correct pizza and they gave me the worst pizza I've ever been served. A huge hole in the pizza which they had to place in the box my hand but there was no toppings so it was super obvious. They use way too big chunks of pineapple so the cheese can't melt. Green peppers tasted... Off. Both of their pinball machines were busted.

Pizza reminds me of a little pizza place in my hometown. Everytime I eat thire pizza it takes me back down memory lane. Thin crust up to New York standards but better with a fresh crispy dough. I had to change my order twice the receptionist was a very patient and kind. Keep up the good work.

Best pizza in town! Been eating out of here for year now and its always great. Today I got the BEST stromboli ever 10/10 perfectttionn 💯 whoever cooked this one Feb 3 thank you masterrrrr u gave me a great early bday present

I've been coming here for years, best pizza around, amazing owners, amazing staff. Best wings around, calzones are delicious and green bean fries that are out of this world. Beer is available.

(1st picture) May 19, 2025 - I usually get their regular cheese and white pizzas, and they nail the simplicity every single time. The flavors are always spot-on, and the crust is great. (2nd picture) September 1, 2025 - Very disappointed on their quality control, don’t know what happened to this pizza, I had a couple slices and called it.