Timothy's Ice Cream

This place was delicious! Not for the germaphobes, but the ice cream was excellent. I ordered the banana split, which I couldn’t quite finish because it was so large. I watched him whip the whip cream fresh. I tried the caramel crunch, strawberry and Dutch chocolate which were all great flavors. 10/10 would go out of my way to eat here again. CASH or CHECK only.

Decent ice cream and flavors. My son enjoyed the maple walnut. The place could use some upgrading.

Been coming here since I was tiny. Still some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had. It’s consistently excellent and fresh. Been open since 1982/3 (I think)- there’s a reason it’s been open so long. Always good to support this local gem. Don’t let the worn appearance fool you. Long live Timothy’s 💓

Located on a not-so-exciting stretch of Fairfield Avenue, Timothy’s still gets significant traffic of the walk-up variety from ice cream seekers and families strolling down the block. The shop features sweet cream ice cream with mix-ins, Cold Stone style, and fresh waffle cones and bowls. Among the popular flavors are locally referenced Black Rock (French vanilla with chocolate-covered almonds) and any flavor with Oreos.

This place is a must visit. The best ice cream I’ve ever had! I tried coffee oreo and I loooved it! I would definitely come back to have this ice cream. Nxt time I will have a double scoop for sure.