Tony Boys Sandwich House Montclair

Just tried for the first time. The sandwich + LTOM was absolutely amazing and all of the ingredients were in the perfect portions. Cutlets are perfectly seasoned and their olive oil is high quality. Best cutlet sandwich around!

From someone whose appetite has been battle-tested and brutally selective, this place doesn’t just serve food; it delivers an experience that resets the standard. Every plate arrives like it has something to prove. The heat is perfect. The texture is intentional. The flavors aren’t loud for attention; they’re composed, disciplined, and unforgettable. Whether you pick it up yourself, sit down and let the moment unfold, or have it delivered to your door, it lands the same way: hot, precise, uncompromised. You can taste the time. You can feel the quality. There’s a level of care in the preparation that goes beyond technique; it feels personal. In a world of rushed kitchens and corner-cutting, this food stands tall. It doesn’t just satisfy hunger. It restores you.

Welcome to Montclair Tony Boys! Had the pleasure of stopping by here yesterday to try out one of many sandwich options on their menu. Opted for the avocado toast & a side of fries & it didn’t disappoint. Was filling without being too heavy & very tasty! The fries were also not oily or greasy. Browsing the menu you’ll find alot of different flavors & combos…and the manager also shared that all the cutlet options can be created with an eggplant substitute! Definitely give this place a try. The vibe is chill & artsy, lots of seating, great central location & 3 parking lots within a 5 min walk. You definitely won’t regret it :)

Can’t stop thinking about the chicken cutlet sandwich I had! Food is delicious, the menu is impressive (including vegetarian options) and service friendly and welcoming!

The salads are our favorite. Salad bowl can feed two people, chicken is well seasoned and the chop in the avocado. small dining area great staff