Troy's Pizzeria

Troy’s has outstanding NY style pizza, Stromboli & stuffed mushrooms. Stromboli & stuffed mushrooms are our favorite go to items. However, if you order Stromboli or stuffed mushrooms make sure you ask if JOHN is working. He is a master of the Stromboli & mushrooms. Last time I ordered a Stromboli when John wasn’t working it was covered in corn meal that made it taste like sawdust and it was a major disappointment. Plus the fillings were meager. John is the man!! I don’t order from here unless he’s working. Their pizza is fairly consistent and about the closest to real New York pizza where I was born & raised so I’m pretty picky about my pizza!! This is a takeout place. There’s a few tables but it’s usually hit as the pizza oven in the restaurant. I don’t recommend dining in.

i went in the middle of the day on a sunday so my expectations werent altogether high. there was a group of what i could only describe as regulars playing poker and chatting it up, which was quite pleasant. The cashier was a young lad, friendly but to the point. I walked in and ordered their spaghetti and meatballs to dine in and a calzone with pepperoni and mushrooms to go. spaghetti took close to 20 minutes to come out came with garlic knots that were decent, one of which wasnt baked all the way through. i have my suspicions that the spaghetti was a "unthaw and bake" affair due to it being in a metal pie pan when it was served. I was a bit peckish so I dug in without a second thought. upon refection it could have used more sauce and the meatballs, while impressive, were dried out on the

Best pizza around in my opinion. Used to go all the time but unfortunately moved far away. If they delivered 1,500 miles, I'd still be ordering frequently. If you live near by or are passing through, I highly recommend. Still on their email list and when I see them coming through, I instantly miss this establishment.

Really impressed with the quality of the pizza. Closest thing I've had in flavor and texture to authentic New York pizza in Florida. Highly recommend!

Wow! Great pizza. True Italian pizza, Oh and the large is a Huge LARGE. It is big. (the pics are a small pizza FYI) We have been looking for a great place in Port St. John's and we have found it. Never had a bad pizza or delivery. Once they gave us a free pizza.