Villa Formia

Won’t be going back to the money hungry spot. I suggest all my fellow nurses & MAs to stop coming here. The owner is completely money hungry & will charge you more than usual price just because you’re wearing a scrub. The plate will be given HALF FULL & the drinks are like $4. Save your money there’s another pizzeria a block down. I for sure won’t be going back. I go every week for the same thing and prices always change depending or not if the older lady (the boss/cashier) is there. Today I specifically pointed out that the plates are half full, usually there’s no lettuce just BARE chicken. So I requested it to be evenly put. And this what they gave me. I kept giving them chances but yeah no when that lady is there prices change & the food portion is cut down. 1 salad $20. HALF FULL . The

Outstanding service, amazing food, delicious dessert. Very good energy and company with owners and staff. Highly recommend.

Edit: 12-4-25 Lost 2 stars today. Vodka pie was somewhat under done the last two orders. Long wait times for delivery are NOT helping as well. Im so disappointed. Consistency is the key. Looks like it was a flash in the pan. If you are ordering delivery CALL DIRECT. They have their own drivers. Excellent pizzeria fare. Capellini cakes are delicious. Vodka pizza and pasta dishes excellent. Love the garlic knots. This is my new go to pizza place. Finally after years of searching and eating substandard slop...a real italian run pizzeria. God be praised!

this review is long overdue…..the pizza here is dope, I order from here constantly…….regular, sicilian, margarita, white, and grandma pizzas are superb with their grandma vodka being particularly noteworthy…. also the quality and quantity of their toppings are worth mentioning…….been living in lynbrook for like 8 years..took me a little while to discover this place…lots of pizza in lynbrook…this place stands out

Incredible pizza. Fresh, crispy. Great specialty slices. Very good for either dine in or takeout. Chicken Caesar pie is amazing. Love the tri color grandma slice (marinara, vodka, pesto). Fried Calamari is a must — always fresh. Chicken parm and chicken piccata are always my go-to entrees. Best pizza and Italian dishes in the area.