Waterloo Pizza at Exxon

I usually give good reviews here, but today I was very disappointed. The pizza I ordered didn't seem fresh at all. It looked very much like it had been sitting for a very long ring. Either that or it was reheated from the previous day. It was very dry, lacked flavor with hardly any cheese on it, the pepperoni was burnt plus it was overcooked. I know when a pizza was made fresh and this definitely was not. I was so disappointed. This is not the first time this has happened to me. Been coming here for a long time. This place has absolutely gone downhill for me. Customer service number did offer to make a new pizza, but after the way the guy who I believe to be the Owner, (old, thin, grey beared man) treated me, I was DONE. Im not getting food remade from anyone angry, for fear that

What an incredible place! Waterloo Pizza is a small take out /delivery restaurant here in Columbia. The pizza is very much in the NY style and delicious! The owner and staff are some of the friendliest and kind people I have dealt with. Amazing diversity of foods all done with quality ingredients and cooked to perfection. My guilty pleasure is the mozzarella sticks, these things are beasts, they are huge and tasty! Hands down Waterloo Pizza and Subs is my favorite pizza experience in Columbia.

Now I can put yall on since I dont live there anymore. I love NY style pizza and my grading rubric is Joe's in Manhattan. While this place is no joes, it satisfied my craving. Thin foldable crust, loaded with meat and cheese and therefore the perfect amount of grease for my hangover. When I was really a fatty I would get two slices from here then slide over to that lil taco truck. Both are so good

If you’re searching for the best pizza in the area, look no further than Columbia Waterloo. Their pizzas are topped with the freshest, most flavorful ingredients, ensuring every bite is a delight. If you’re new to Columbia, skip the big chain pizza places and discover what locals have cherished for over 20 years—you won’t be disappointed!

YES! YES! YES! From the kind greeting at the door to the last bite, everything was perfect. This place is where you want to go for perfectly baked pizza 🍕 and delicious chicken wings. The menu even has burgers 🍔 which I have not yet tried! I'm so excited to have found a local pizza spot. Highly recommended for pizza lovers. Everything is delicious. Get the pepperoni or Supreme. My faves. Also, the lemon pepper wings 🍋 🌶 !! So crunchy and flavored just right!