Wheated

Wheated probably takes the crown for some of the best specialty pizzas in Brooklyn. We absolutely loved our dinner here. The space has a fast, lively energy that makes it feel like you’re in on a neighborhood favorite, and the food completely lives up to the buzz. One of the coolest touches is that every pizza is named after a Brooklyn neighborhood, which makes the menu fun to explore. I ordered the Flatbush and it honestly surprised me in the best way. I had never tried eggplant on pizza before, but it worked incredibly well. It added a rich, savory depth without feeling heavy, and the crust had that perfect balance of chewy and crisp. The cocktails were also a pleasant surprise. It’s not always expected at a pizza spot, but they were thoughtfully made and paired perfectly with the meal

Definitely one of the TOP Pie spots in Brooklyn! Love the aesthetics! The bathroom door blending into the wall is cool! I don’t remember that last time I was here to dine-in but that was a while ago. I’ve done both take-out & dine-in here. There were a couple tables available but they do fill up fast! I found a seat by the bar right away! I ordered a drink while I waited I don’t remember the name but it was good. The Pizza came after like 15min or so it wasn’t a long wait. I was really happy with its presentation, flavor & texture etc… The cheese was perfectly melted, the crust was crispy & sauce was great! They definitely didn’t disappoint & piled high the toppings for the supreme part of the pie. I would definitely get the supreme again though next time I wanna try a white pie mayb

First Impressions & Vibe: We popped in on a Saturday with no reservation and were seated within 10 minutes. The place was busy, or “bumping,” as you said. The atmosphere is cool, casual, lively, neighborhood pizza spot energy. ⸻ 🥗 Salad + Starters We tried the Tuscan Kale salad. The cheese was nice and nutty, and the walnuts added a good texture. But the dressing was too acidic — the moment you bite in, the tang hits first and lingers. It overpowered the greens instead of complementing them. ⸻ 🍕 Pizza & Side We went with a classic New York style pie, 12-inch split between two people. Served correctly, satisfying size — we didn’t leave hungry. It’s the kind of pizza you expect from a pizza place: decent cheese, but teg crust was BURNT , but overall “good.” But I have to call out a f

I just moved over to the Flatbush area from the city and I was looking for a solid local pizza spot you can dine it at. This is the one! Been twice and both times the pizza was phenomenal (top 10 in all of NYC good). The atmosphere and ambiance is great and it is good for families or just a date night. I highly recommend this spot and I will become a regular soon!

We popped in and it was busy. Luckily they had 3 seats at the bar. 10/10 would recommend. We got 2 12" pizzas and it was perfect for 3 people. We took home a few slices. Both pizzas were delicious. The ceasar salad was also outstanding