Whitetail Inn

Don't sleep on the Whitetail Inn!! We almost didn't go because of some of the bad reviews here, but I'm sure thankful we didn't let those stop us. We had the most amazing dinner! Pre-dinner cocktails and then started with the bacon wrapped chestnuts with a cherry sauce...killer appetizer!! I had the King prime rib, which was supposed to be 16 oz, but I swear it was easily 24 to 28 ounces. It was cooked to perfection and the au jus was seasoned very well. I brought more home than I could possibly eat there. My wife had the Mediterranean Haddock and she still cannot express how yummy it was. We finished with a couple of after dinner cocktails at the bar. Overall a FABULOUS evening!!

Appetizers were great. I got the filet and it was overcooked but the staff was very accommodating and rectified the situation. Loved the fireplace and the atmosphere. Our server was very friendly and a great personality. Would definitely go back.

Initially had a cocktail at the bar. Don is such a personable bartender! Live music during dinner that was really a nice touch. The service was good. The food was absolutely amazing, not to mention the beautiful view of the golf course and the interior atmosphere. The inn is a magnificent structure. We can't wait to visit again.

I really try to like this place, but only go there every five years or so because they always disappoint. I love the building, and appreciate the wood structure and fireplace. Went tonight as a table of three. We are sat down and waited five minutes and the table next to us gets seated. Instantly that table receives service, but we wait another handful of minutes before a server finally comes to us. Right away I could tell she was distracted and they had no sections as the waiters/waitresses were jumping all over the place, which didn’t help. We debated between cheese curds and a stuffed mushroom appetizer. We ordered the mushrooms which came with little to no mushroom in it. Also, we only received two plates for three people. They were basically cheese stuffed curds with little mushroom

A perfect experience!! When me and a friend went, the Filet was perfect, the broccolini was tasty, and the baked potato was exactly to my satisfaction! It was my birthday week, and the server gave me a free slice of Lemon Berry Mascarpone with a candle!! The piano man (Dale?? I dont remember his name) was a great pianist! Everything was perfect and would 100% go back!